Friday, March 9, 2012

Survivor Week 4- Takin' It to the Tribal



I'm going to take a quick moment here to talk about the fact that for the first time in Survivor history a tribe won immunity and then decided to go to tribal council anyway.  While this was ridiculously dumb, as noted in my docking of 5 points to all members of the men's tribe, it was far from the dumbest move in Survivor history.

Anything done as a team can't possibly be in the same conversation as someone giving up an individual idol and walking out the door, or even as recently as Ozzy intentionally getting voted off so that he could come back from Redemption Island.  Sure, he did get to come back, but it was still dumb to take that chance...dumber than this move by the men.

Think about it.  Only one out of those nine guys was leaving the game on that day, so yes it was unbelievably stupid for Bill in this case, but he had no idea he was going to be the one going home at the time.  So again, you can't really put him in the category of dumbest players either.

The fact that this entire tribe is allowing Colton to make all their decisions for them is probably the dumbest thing of the season so far.  This spoiled brat - admittedly by him during this episode - is annoyed by Bill because he's poor, so you're all willing to head to tribal council earlier to vote him out?  This is the same Colton that was hanging out with the girls' tribe a few days ago because he had nothing in common with any of you, right?  Okay, just checking.

When did we miss the part where the group of misfits decided that Colton was their leader?  It seemed like at one point it just happened, and it will probably be the downfall of the guys.  I have no problem getting rid of your stronger players - I'd prefer it to come after you've won a few more team challenges - but it's something you're going to want to do at some point.  My issue is with the reasoning.  You don't vote someone out because they're annoying.  That's just playing Survivor emotionally, and that won't ever work.

Champions League


Larry

Michael -72: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), W4 (+7)= -60
Kat -65: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= -54
Jonas +12: Tribal (-5), W4 (+7)= +14
Tarzan +18: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), W4 (+7)= +30

Last Week -107: Team Total= -70

Me

Jay -53: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), W4 (+7)= -41
Chelsea -111: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= -100
Monica +4: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= +15
Colton +22: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), W4 (+7)= +34

Last Week -138: Team Total= -92


Jack

Troyzan -23: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), W4 (+7)= -11
Christina -50: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= -39
Kourtney -45
Bill -22: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), Votes (-28)= -45

Last Week -140: Team Total= -140



Jaydon

Matt -100
Kim -91: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= -80
Alicia +14: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= +25
Nina -24

Last Week -201: Team Total= -179




Free Agents
Leif +27: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), Votes (-4), W4 (+7)= +35
Sabrina +29: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= +40

Developmental League

Tippy

Troyzan: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), W4 (+7)= +12
Kat: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= +11
Colton: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), W4 (+7)= +12
Monica: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= +11

Week 4= +46, Team Total= +130

Marsh

Jay: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), W4 (+7)= +12
Chelsea: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= +11
Bill: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), Votes (-28)= -23
Christina: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= +11

Week 4= +11, Team Total= +95




Mags

Matt
Kim: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= +11
Alicia: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= +11
Tarzan: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), W4 (+7)= +12

Week 4= +34, Team Total= +86

Rizzo

Michael: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), W4 (+7)= +12
Jonas: Tribal (-5), W4 (+7)= +2
Kourtney
Nina

Week 4= +14, Team Total= +11




Free Agents
Leif: Immunity (+10), Tribal (-5), Votes (-4), W4 (+7)= +8
Sabrina: Reward (+4), W4 (+7)= +11

No comments:

Post a Comment