Fantasy Idol Results- A Real Paige Turner

For all of those that feel it is better to be awful and get killed by the judges than to be mediocre and get unnoticed (I'm staring right at you Sepinwall), tonight's results proved that to be completely wrong. Paige Miles put forth one of the most heinous performances this week. She was absolutely murdered by the judges worse than I've seen in the past few seasons. And yes she went home tonight without even getting the chance to sing for the judges save.

I am now one for two, as my prediction Andrew Garcia wasn't even in the bottom three. Paige was joined by Tim Urban, for the second straight week, and Katie Stevens on the chopping block. After Katie was sent back to the couches, Timmy followed her and Paige was sent packing. That's right Simon didn't even give her the chance to fight as he told her she was 100% gone no matter what happened. Thanks for saving us the time Sime, but it was kinda cruel.

And now for tonight's guest performers...The Disney Channel All-Stars. People can make fun of Miley for not being the right person to have as a mentor on Idol, but you cannot deny that she killed it up on stage tonight. Her When I Look at You was incredible and her interview with Seacrest afterward just as good. On the flip side, I was not so impressed with Joey Jonas and Demi Lovato. Their uneventful Make a Wave was nothing to write home about. The sparks between them on stage does keep my hopes high for Camp Rock 2 this summer though.

Larry takes a big lead in the fantasy results as he is now the only one with three contestants left. Rizzo is hanging on by a thread as his only player left, Katie Stevens, was a bottom three member this week.

Fantasy Scores

The Rock Bodega
Casey James- Safe (11)= 11
Janell Wheeler
Tim Urban- Bottom 3 (-5), Safe (11)= 6
Lee DeWyze- Safe (11)= 11
Week 5= 28 Total= 64

You're Coming With Me Leather
Andrew Garcia- Safe (11)= 11
Paige Miles- Bottom 3 (-5), Eliminated (-10)= -15
Aaron Kelly- Safe (11)= 11
John Park
Week 5= 7 Total= 42

Diabolical Haters
Didi Benami- Safe (11)= 11
Lilly Scott
Lacey Brown
Michael Lynch- Safe (11)= 11
Week 5= 22 Total= 42

The Curlgar
Ashley Rodriguez
Joe Muñoz
Haley Vaughn
Siobhan Magnus- Safe (11)= 11
Week 5= 11 Total= 18

Splash Downs All Around
Todrick Hall
Crystal Bowersox- Safe (11)= 11
Tyler Grady
Michelle Delamor
Week 5= 11 Total= 17

HashTag Katie Stevens Is Only 16
Katie Stevens- Bottom 3 (-5), Safe (11)= 6
Jermaine Sellers
Katelyn Epperly
Alex Lambert
Week 5= 6 Total= 11